Playing Ep 11

What people are saying

• BoldWei

  Overall 8.5

  Story 8.5,  Acting 8.5,  Music 8.5,  Rewatch Value 7.5

  Content Advisory: Viewer Discretion for Unflinching Portrayals
  
  The drama in question navigates the seldom-trodden path in the realm of Chinese costume dramas by not shying away from the portrayal of sexual violence against its female characters. It's an aspect that demands potential viewers to exercise discretion about their emotional boundaries before delving into the narrative. Beyond these jarring moments, however, lies a tapestry typical of the wuxia genre—brimming with high-stakes adventure, quests for vengeance, valiant expressions of pride, palpable themes of justice, heart-warming bonds of camaraderie,...

  true companionship, and the valiant spirit of self-sacrifice.
  
  Our protagonist, a resident of an isolated mountain area portrayed by Zeng Shun Xi, embodies an infectious optimism as he descends into the wider world, a stark contrast to his later traveling companion portrayed by Liu Yuning, who exudes ambition with undertones of ruthlessness. This journey of discovery intertwines their paths with another companion and throws them into the complex web of "jianghu" politics. They cross paths with a leader of a righteous faction, a character brought to life by Chen Chuhe, whose frail health juxtaposes his inner strength and moral fortitude. As the leader of this group, his need for formidable allies leads to a bond of brotherhood among the three men.
  
  Zeng Shun Xi’s portrayal is magnetic, adapting his character from an innocently wide-eyed wanderer to a significantly more composed and grounded individual, evidencing a remarkable flexibility in his acting prowess. Likewise, Liu Yuning delivers a spine-chilling performance, his transition from a calm and self-interested individual to someone consumed by his lust for power is portrayed with an intensity that resonates long after the screen fades to black.
  
  Chen Chuhe's depiction of the ailing yet formidable leader is incredibly moving. His struggles, though physical, never overshadow the compelling nature of his determination and action-filled encounters which are carried out with perfect authenticity.
  
  Complement the aforementioned performances with Yang Chaoyue, whose character evolution has shown a noteworthy improvement compared to previous roles, filling audiences with anticipation for her future work.
  
  Critical Perspective
  
  The series undoubtedly embraces its wuxia roots yet seems encumbered by less than stellar screenwriting at times, characterized by less mature logic, narrative discrepancies, and a myriad of inconsistencies. One might argue that it missed a golden opportunity to weave the theme of brotherhood more intrinsically into its fabric, sometimes only grazing the concept when it promised to delve deep.
  
  Narrative pace occasionally wanes amidst unfolding romantic complexities, with a climactic shift in leadership towards the conclusion feeling somewhat abrupt and out of left field. As per the genre's tradition, characters introduced at the onset are often not part of the concluding landscape, a bittersweet hallmark of such epics.
  
  Any shortcomings, though, are outweighed by the adeptly choreographed action sequences and swordplay that are sure to impress. The underlying currents of the drama probe philosophical questions about life's true meaning, the contrast between merely surviving and truly living, and uphold a critical view of ideological freedom versus authoritarian control.
  
  The narrative draws interesting parallels with modern political discourse—an exploration of how power can corrupt, a reflection of governmental failings, and an outline of the need for courageous figures to counteract societal decay.
  
  For connoisseurs of the wuxia genre, this series will resonate as a valuable addition. Despite stumbles in script crafting, it remains a recommendable watch, particularly for those seeking to immerse themselves in a narrative that manages to echo contemporary issues through the lens of historic dramatization.

• happywu

  Overall 8

  Story 7.5,  Acting 8.5,  Music 8.5,  Rewatch Value 8

  Please be aware this review might reveal crucial plot points
  Heroes need not tread the well-worn paths of righteousness to capture our imaginations in this shadow-laced, melodramatic entry into the realm of wuxia. The question posed by its evocative Chinese title—translating to a contemplation of what truly defines a 'hero'—sets the tone for a narrative where our champion is for us to decide.
  
  This tale stands apart, a narrative gem sown from the fertile imagination of an author who, while not often mentioned alongside the titans...

  of the genre, crafts a tale with a cynicism that challenges and intrigues. Within these woven tales, the martial artists, etched in lore and armed with legendary swords, dance a ballet of might and mastery; one can only know the victor when steel clashes against steel.
  
  Achieving a visual poetry that encapsulates the genre's heart, from its sprawling wilds to its fatalist undercurrents, Li Muge's lens is almost spellbinding—albeit the sword fights occasionally disappoint with their overindulgent choreography and lack of the visceral impact one might expect.
  
  Our characters, an array of brilliantly realized and multifaceted individuals, wield their complexities like the weapons they bear. From the charismatic, to the heartbroken, and the capriciously fanatical to the enigmatically astute—each brings a color to the tapestry of jianghu. Among them, the younger idols, while outshined, provide credible performances despite the obvious challenges their intricate roles present.
  
  Our journey begins with a young, honor-bound character entrusted with a box of mystery, his path weaving with that of a deadly ambitious warrior and a well-born woman dodging matrimonial expectations. Their alliance with a noble faction pits them against an antithetical group, drawing a line between high-minded idealism and practical opportunism. Here, martial talent blooms on both sides, each with its own moral compass.
  
  Amidst the collision of ideologies, one character's ambition becomes his undoing; his transformation from a powerful individual to a tragic villain is at once compelling and heart-wrenching—a case of character potential betrayed by an inexplicable softening from the writers.
  
  The villains, while infused with possibility, receive underdeveloped resolutions at the story's climax. At its core, the tale becomes a lament, leading to a blood-soaked inevitability painted in melodramatic strokes. The final words of one of the most central characters resonate with the weight of a haunting poem, adhering to a theme of solitude in valor.
  
  As we ponder over the notion of heroes, the takeaway is that a true hero need not adhere to the genre's stereotypical virtues. It is in being true to one's own ideals that one can be the hero of their own story. Some characters stand out in this narrative, with bonds of love and fidelity that feel the most genuine and tragically resonant.
  
  Mixed emotions trail the denouement of this drama. Despite its potential to soar, it succumbs to certain narrative missteps, even though the foundations laid by its source material provide a compelling enough escape into its richly constructed world. Awarding it a rating that veers on the cusp of mediocrity feels just, yet the presence of an unforgettable character, playing the role of an unlikely hero, elevates it decidedly. In the end, this tale may lead one to conclude that in the absence of heroes, one must become their own.

• ancientrobocop

  Overall 8

  Story 8,  Acting 10,  Music 8,  Rewatch Value 8

  Embodying the Spirit of Valor: A Journey through the Epitome of Selflessness
  
  As the final credits rolled on the series I've devotedly followed, I find myself in contemplation of the kinetic energy and prowess that coursed through the screen. The display of martial expertise, particularly from the likes of Baron Chen, Liu Yu Ning, and Joseph Zeng, was a spectacular affair, a testament to their dedication and the post-production team's meticulous efforts. The cohesive work of lighting and choreography has elevated the story, making the action...

  not just a spectacle, but a narrative-driven ballet of punches and kicks that merit a standing ovation for the entire cast and crew. The helmsman of this visual vessel has unequivocally steered the series with a vision so vivid that the tale virtually leaps off the screen and into the annals of outstanding cinematic portrayal.
  
  Nonetheless, amid the high-flying kicks and the clashing of unparalleled valor, I sensed a void where the heart of the story should have been. The series, while not heavily romantic in nature, faced moments of emotional aridity. The anticipation for the sparks that should fly between characters, such as the pairing suggested by the talents of Baron Chen and Meng Ziyi, or Joseph Zeng's captivating tango with Yang Chao Yue—even these poised elements failed to ignite the embers of passion expected to warm the viewers’ hearts. The absence of blossoming romances—normally the soul of such narratives—was felt.
  
  It's not lost on me that the foundation of this series is its adrenaline-fueled wuxia roots. Yet, in a world as expressive as ours, the lack of a love story can render the landscape somewhat colorless, as the sheer brilliance of combining a resonant romantic thread with spectacular fight sequences can often elevate a tale from being merely watched to being felt. Nonetheless, perfection is a mirage in the vast desert of storytelling, and every piece of art constructs its resonance through both its loud triumphs and its silent shortcomings.
  
  Having been a spectator to numerous wuxia tales of old, which have wildly varied in their capacity to weave together romance with action—and indeed, in their ability to conclude on a satisfying note—I harbor respect for this "Heroes" narrative. It remains authentic and true to its core despite the critiques that orbit it. While each viewer may interpret the storyline through their own unique lens, casting their shadows of subjectivity upon it, the series accomplishes that which it set out to do: to redefine heroism.
  
  And why does it emerge a cut above the rest? Because it seeks not to glitter with the false allure of a conqueror's ambition, but rather, it delves into the essence of what a hero represents—a beacon of hope, unfaltering in the quest to protect the meek. Villainy, no matter how potent, is transient in this world, and this tale speaks to that universal truth: the ultimate victors are those who assume power not with a heavy hand, but with an open heart. Thus, the greatest champion is the silent guardian, the warrior altruist—a defender of those who cannot defend themselves.

• quickliu

  Overall 8.5

  Story 8,  Acting 9,  Music 8,  Rewatch Value 7.5

  In the lavish realm of martial arts legends, stands a protagonist who epitomizes the virtues of a Wuxia hero—unblemished, altruistic, and the embodiment of justice. The actor tasked with bringing this beacon of virtue to life hits the mark, capturing the character's initial naivety, his evolving sense of responsibility, and the anguish that so often shadows the revered warriors of this mythical landscape.
  
  The emotional crux of the series lies in the deeply rooted bonds between the trio of blood brothers. Love interests, though present,...

  take a backseat in this narrative, making way for the stronger ties of brotherhood. Although the primary heroine's character arc may not be as robustly developed, and she may seem a frivolous and somewhat pampered presence, she still manages to win hearts with her practicality and agreeable nature, contributing to a relationship refreshingly free of tedious misunderstandings.
  
  This saga places our hero amidst a rich tapestry of characters—a hallmark of Wuxia storytelling—spanning friends, familial connections, venerated elders, and formidable adversaries. While some side characters serve as simple narrative tools, others grab your attention from the get-go. The performer assigned the role of the enigmatic and complex Di Feijing, in particular, shines in their portrayal, leaving an indelible mark. Moreover, the introduction to the stage of a respected actor as an honored and astute martial arts authority within this universe is nothing short of impressive.
  
  As one who hasn't pored over the novel from which this tapestry is woven, I encounter the drama in its purely televised form. To my satisfaction, it stands as one of the more commendable Wuxia series I've had the pleasure to witness of late. A feast for the eyes, the production excels visually, and the cast adeptly executes the martial arts sequences with a credible finesse that belies the commonplace pitfalls of over-stylized action.
  
  Admittedly, the series does waver at times in its narrative flow and character progression; however, these foibles do not render the storyline chaotic or trite as some critiques suggest. Far from the mangled endings that often pepper the genre, this story keeps a safe distance from such storytelling calamities. Although the series may not top my list for repeat viewings, it justified the investment of my time. Disregard the lukewarm public reviews at the time of penning this—this endeavor, referred to here as Heroes, is undervalued and merits acknowledgment more in accord with its higher domestic ratings, proving there's an appreciative audience for its craft.

• quickuranus83

  Overall 8.5

  Story 7,  Acting 9.5,  Music 10,  Rewatch Value 7.5

  In a world steeped in the tradition of Chinese martial arts tales, a series recently graced the screen, promising a return to pure wuxia, devoid of overt romantic narratives that often eclipse the core of such stories. My intrigue was piqued by this and was further anchored by the presence of a certain male and female lead whom I had been ardently following in their artistic journeys.
  
  Delving into the essence of the series, one cannot help but admire the depth and complexity woven into the...

  characters. Two in particular captured my admiration: Su Meng Zhen and DFJ. The former, a beacon of righteousness, held steadfast to his principles until his final moments; the latter, a morally ambiguous figure whose fierce loyalty and honorable exit marked him as unforgettable. The camaraderie that blossomed among these characters and their compatriots within the Sunset House was one of the show’s triumphs.
  
  The narrative didn’t shy away from darker shades, interspersing moments of levity and warmth amidst its serious tone. The sparingly showcased action sequences were well-executed, and, refreshingly, new characters were seamlessly integrated into the story, ensuring coherent arcs and memorable presences.
  
  Focusing on the female leads, LC's character shifted from a naive ingenue to someone who had to withstand the tempest of loss, adapting with remarkable resilience. Her journey, interlaced with SMZ, was beautifully tragic. Meanwhile, XY stood out for her fortitude and complexity, providing a noteworthy counterpart to the main hero.
  
  Speaking of heroes, the adored WXS—though a later bloomer—earned his place in the pantheon of series champions. His growth was both relatable and worth rooting for. However, for me, the distinction of THE hero resides not in a singular figure, but in the collective might of SMZ and DFJ, each embodying different facets of what makes a hero shine.
  
  A nod to the powerful performances cannot go unsaid, especially the captivating renditions of a certain character by LYN, whose descent into madness was portrayed with chilling credibility, despite the narrative's failing to grant him a descent proportionate to his potential.
  
  The series' aesthetics were a feast for the senses, with intricate sets, detailed costuming, and a particularly haunting OST that echoed the show's intensity.
  
  Yet, not all shone brightly; the stylistic choices in hair design took a puzzling turn, with some characters appearing as though they were auditioning for an avant-garde pet show, detracting from the gravitas of their roles.
  
  Additionally, the mismanaged evolution of a potentially iconic villain and the exaggerated frailty of the FL, who too often succumbed to whining, marred the narrative, robbing certain scenes of their emotional impact.
  
  While novel purists might not find this adaptation faithful, the essence of wuxia endures in the brotherhood betrayals, strategic confrontations, and those moments of human connectivity that rise above adversity. Despite its flaws, the series elicits a definite recommendation for its ambitious genre endeavors, and I remain without regret in my anticipation and consumption of this markedly unique dramatic offering.