I had the chance to catch this movie in our local cinema, and while I won't go as far as calling it a bad movie, I have to admit that it's quite mediocre. But let's focus on the positive aspects first! The special effects are remarkably well done, miles ahead of the obviously fake CGI animation in the TV drama. Additionally, I found myself preferring the lead actress in the movie. Liu Yifei looks more endearing to me than Yang Mi in the drama. It...
did take some time for me to warm up to TV Yang Mi. Oh, and the pacing is fast, almost too fast at times, which means you won't get bored watching it.
Now, onto the not-so-great parts. Regardless of whether you've seen the TV drama or not, this movie has some significant shortcomings. If you haven't seen the drama, the plot will be quite baffling. It's important to note that special effects can't make up for a lack of a cohesive story. The constant back and forth between the present and the past was initially okay, but it ultimately diminishes the impact and can be confusing for moviegoers without any background knowledge. Additionally, while I understand the need to cut down on characters and side stories, there were important parts left unexplained. On the bright side, the acting is passable, although not brilliant.
If you have seen the drama, the story will be understandable (thanks to your pre-knowledge), but the movie itself might disappoint you. Chinese netizens have been hilariously pointing out some ludicrous parts, like the audience laughing when certain supporting characters' costumes appeared on screen - definitely not the reaction the filmmakers were aiming for! Thankfully, the lead actors' costumes are (mostly) on point, although even one of them elicited laughter during a supposedly dramatic scene due to an over-the-top costume. But let's not dwell on the costumes too much. What really left me unsatisfied was the lack of emotional connection. Actor Yang Yang isn't terrible, but if you've seen the drama, it's hard not to compare him to Mark Chao. Many dramatic scenes fell flat, and one of the highlights of the TV drama, the reunion between the lead actor and actress after a separation, was reduced to more of a "boy meets girl for the first time" rom-com vibe in the movie.
For fans of the novel or the TV series, don't be discouraged by this review. Go ahead and watch the movie, but keep your expectations low. You'll enjoy the beautifully shot scenes and be able to relive the story. Time will fly by quickly, that's for sure. However, for non-fans, I recommend staying away. It will only leave you baffled and wondering what all the fuss is about.